Tema: Russ. rev. - højrefløjens angreb

Russ. rev. - højrefløjens angreb

Kevin Murphy: Conceding the Russian Revolution to liberals
International Socialism Journal nr. 126, apr 10 – side 197
Note: A review of Simon Pirani, The Russian Revolution in Retreat, 1920-24: Soviet Workers and the New Communist Elite (Routledge, 2008), £20.00
Readers of this journal who have not had the unpleasant experience of wading through liberal studies of the Soviet working class will nevertheless find the narrative itself all too familiar. These studies acknowledge that there was indeed a popular revolution in 1917, but the nasty and intransigent Lenin and Trotsky refused to share power with the “moderate” socialists.
 

Megan Trudell: Setting the record straight (Robert Service: "Lenin: A Biography")
International Socialism Journal nr. 89, dec 00 – side 101
Note: It is a feature of the debate surrounding the Russian Revolution that the ideological fallout from the collapse of the Soviet Union has disoriented many historians on the left, and that conservative historians have made the most of the confusion to produce works 'proving' the direct link between Lenin's revolutionary government and Stalin's regime. If Robert Service's book is anything to go by, it can only be assumed that the absence of politically rigorous opposition has made conservative historians ill-tempered and lazy.
 

Ida H. Jakobsen + Mikkel Birk Jespersen: “Den hemmelige Lenin” i TV2: TV-løgn om Lenin
Socialistisk Arbejderavis nr. 175, sep 99 – side 8
Note: DR2 viste søndag d. 8. august en såkaldt dokumentar-udsendelse med titlen “Den hemmelige Lenin”. Programmet er et af de ypperste eksempler på borgerskabets ihærdige indsats for at tilsværte den revolutionære, socialistiske tradition.
 

Robert Service: Did Lenin lead to Stalin?
International Socialism Journal nr. 55, jun 92 – side 77
Note: John Rees' 'In defence of October', published in International Socialism 52 has proven to be a controversial account of the Bolshevik revolution. Here we publish contributions from Robert Service, author of a biography of Lenin and The Russian Revolution 1900-27, Robin Blackburn, editor of New Left Review, Sam Farber, author of Before Stalinism, and David Finkel of the American magazine Against the Current, plus a rejoinder from John Rees.
 

Ågot Berger + Freddie Nielsen: Den russiske revolution: Oprør eller kup? Førte Lenin til Stalin?
International Socialisme nr. 1, feb 92 – side 5
Note: De politiske revolutioner i Østeuropa har bragt højrefløjen i offensiven med argumentet, at stalinismens død er socialismens død. Langt ind på venstrefløjen har begivenhederne skabt forvirring omkring hvor meget i den socialistiske tradition, det er muligt at forsvare.
 

Der blev fundet 5 artikler

 

Til hovedgruppe – Til temaoversigt

 

Toppen af siden